Will Johnny Manziel Make a Good NFL Quarterback?

No doubt, Cleveland needs to snag this guy. Johnny Manziel, the former Heisman Trophy winner and a controversial figure in the NFL, has impressive qualities that make him a valuable prospect. Let's explore whether he has what it takes to succeed in the professional ranks.

Scout's Evaluation of Johnny Manziel

Five things scouts will watch during Johnny Manziel's pro day can give us an idea of his potential in the NFL. Here is a breakdown of his strengths and potential weaknesses based on a recent analysis by NFL Media analyst Daniel Jeremiah.

1. Size

Manziel's size (5'11", 207 lbs) may raise concerns regarding his durability and physical limitations. He is described as having only free agent size like some legendary QBs such as Drew Brees, Cam Newton, and Doug Flutie. However, size alone doesn't determine success in the NFL.

2. Speed

Manziel's speed (8.5 on a scale of 1-9) is commendable, particularly his sudden movements. Though he might not be as fast as an elite player like RG3, his agility is a significant advantage on the field.

3. Arm Strength

His arm strength (6-7 on a scale of 1-10) is above average for a mobile quarterback but not on par with the likes of John Elway. Manziel's unique ability to throw off-balance and on the move showcases his accuracy and pocket presence.

4. Accuracy and Touch

On the Move: He scores an excellent 8, similar to Aaron Rodgers. This indicates his capacity to remain accurate and focused during quick movements. From the Pocket: His accuracy and touch in this area receive an 8-9, demonstrating his ability to maintain precision under pressure.

5. Leadership and Intelligence

Manziel scores impressively in leadership (8.5 out of 10) and poise (8 out of 10), attributes that are crucial for a quarterback. His ability to lead his team and handle pivotal moments on the field are his strongest traits.

6. Upside and Downside

While there are questions about his future due to size concerns, Manziel's unique skills and potential "ball out" playing style in a spread offense could be his saving grace. The case against him includes his small stature and mechanical limitations, but advocates highlight his exceptional accuracy and innate game IQ.

Why He Could Be a Star

Manziel has the potential to be a star if given the right opportunities. His ability to hold his own against powerhouses like Alabama, where he demonstrated exceptional performance, suggests that his skills can translate to the next level. His playmaking ability, as seen in games against top-tier defenses, indicates that he has the potential to thrive in the NFL.

The Case for Drafting Manziel

If a team can provide the right system for Manziel, particularly one that allows for him to be a mobile quarterback, he could be a dynamite addition to their roster. The comparison to Fran Tarkenton, a legendary quarterback who held numerous passing records, provides a compelling argument for giving Manziel a chance.

Conclusion

While not every team will embrace Manziel, his unique set of skills and potential make him worthy of consideration. For teams like the Houston Texans, Jacksonville Jaguars, Cleveland Browns, and others with top-eight picks, Manziel should be a strong candidate to consider. His rapid rise as a pro prospect and his impressive performance both on and off the field warrant serious consideration from NFL scouts and front offices.