Why Drew Pearson Deserves a Spot in the Hall of Fame

The untold story of Drew Pearson, an ex-Cowboys star receiver, is a testament to his clutch ability and unwavering performance under pressure. Despite not being selected for the Hall of Fame, Pearson's presence on the field, particularly in the fourth quarter, significantly influenced the outcomes of many crucial games. He is a fitting candidate for the Hall of Fame, and adding him would further enhance the prestige of this legendary honor.

Overlooked Talent

Pearson was not an overwhelmingly physical player. Physically, he wasn't particularly big or fast. His numbers, generated during the mid-70s (often referred to as the 'Dead Ball Era'), were respectable but not world-class. However, his contributions were often overshadowed by more flamboyant players. Hailing from the same team, many of his contemporaries, such as Lynn Swann and John Jefferson, garnered more public attention with their sensational plays.

For instance, Swann and Jefferson were revered for their ability to make impossible catches, performing feats that seemed nearly impossible. Pearson's style was more nuanced and strategic. While Swann and Jefferson were known for acrobatic, one-handed tricks, Pearson's routes were precise and reliable. His performance wasn't as flashy, but it was incredibly effective in maintaining possession during critical moments of the game.

Clutch Performance

It was Pearson's clutch ability that set him apart. Many games would see him as an inconspicuous figure until the final drive, when he would suddenly come alive. His late-game performances were critical, often making crucial catches on third or fourth down, keeping drives alive and turning the tide of the game. His ability to turn up the intensity when it mattered most was unmatched.

Pearson's clutch performances are etched in NFL history. Notable among them is the so-called 'original Hail Mary' where he made the game-winning touchdown catch in a come-from-behind victory against Atlanta during the 1980 playoffs. Additionally, Pearson's famous catch on Thanksgiving Day in 1974, where he led the team to a victory against the Redskins with a backup quarterback throwing to him, was a defining moment.

Five Legendary Incidents

By far the most memorable moment was the 1975 Thanksgiving Day game against the Redskins, where he caught a well-placed pass from backup Clint Longley to score the winning touchdown. His performance earned him the moniker 'Turkey Lurkey'. He made the famous 'Hail Mary' catch in the 1980 playoffs, which was considered one of the greatest comebacks in NFL history. Another remarkable moment was during the 1981 championship game when he snatched a 31-yard pass from Danny White in the final seconds, nearly pulling off a touchdown. This highlight nearly overshadowed Dwight Clark's famous catch, highlighting Pearson's importance to the Cowboys. In his prime, he was Roger Staubach and Danny White's primary target in late-game situations, contributing significantly to their success. His clutch performances were so consistently impressive that opposing teams often puzzled over his sudden appearances in the fourth quarter. It was a testament to his ability to perform under the most intense pressure.

Comparison with Other Legends

There have been numerous receivers with better numbers, better size, better speed, and better talent. Many of them, such as Lynn Swann and Cris Carter, have been inducted into the Hall of Fame. However, what sets Drew Pearson apart is his consistent ability to perform in critical situations. His performances were not flashy but dependable, often surprising his opponents and teammates alike.

Without the late-game heroics of Pearson, it's plausible that some of these legendary moments would have been significantly altered. Just as Eric Wright's coverage prevented Pearson's final play from turning into a touchdown in the 1981 championship game, his clutch ability may have propelled Clayton "Cleats" Murdock or Eric Metcalf to HOF status.

The Case for Inclusion

The case for including Drew Pearson in the Hall of Fame is compelling. His consistent clutch performances, coupled with his unwavering leadership, have been pivotal to the success of the Dallas Cowboys. While he may have been overshadowed by his contemporaries, his legacy is one of resilience and determination under the pressure of the game.

Admitting Pearson into the Hall of Fame would not only recognize his contributions but also inspire future generations of players to perform at their best when it matters most. In light of his significant impact on the game of football, it's high time for Pearson to receive the recognition he deserves.

And, while they're at it, the same consideration should apply to Cliff Branch. Branch's consistent clutch performances, combined with his exceptional receptions, give him a strong case for Hall of Fame enshrinement, just like Pearson's.