What Should the Browns Do with Deshaun Watson: A Deep Dive

The Cleveland Browns face a critical decision regarding their starting quarterback, Deshaun Watson, following his recent poor performance against the Dallas Cowboys. Adding to the complexity, Watson is currently under investigation for alleged violations of the NFL’s Personal Conduct Policy, while his shoulder injuries and high guaranteed salary add further challenges. This article will delve into the possible scenarios and the best course of action for the Browns.

The Current Situation and Issues

Watson's recent performance against the Cowboys was below standard for a professional quarterback. His throws were notably off, despite being a capable and experienced player. This poor performance, combined with ongoing litigation and the speculation that he has not recovered fully from his shoulder injuries, raises significant concerns about his immediate and long-term contribution to the team.

High Guaranteed Salary and NFL Contract

The Browns signed Deshaun Watson to a highly lucrative contract with significant guarantees. This contract, along with the high percentage of salaries guaranteed, makes it financially challenging for the team to make drastic changes. Cutting Watson would come with 'dead money'—the Browns would still have to pay significant portions of the guaranteed salary, which cannot be recovered even if Watson is released early.

Given this high cost, the Browns may be compelled to stick with Watson and hope for gradual improvement. However, the team should prepare for the possibility that Watson's performance and overall health may not improve significantly, which could make the situation financially untenable in the long run.

Legal and Conduct Issues

The allegations against Watson not only affect his performance on the field but also have legal implications for the Browns. If Watson is proven to have violated the NFL’s Personal Conduct Policy, the Browns could initiate legal proceedings to void his contract. This would potentially allow them to recover the guaranteed money paid to him, although it would be a long and costly process.

Until the investigation concludes, the Browns must tread carefully. While they may be tempted to cut ties with Watson, the financial penalties associated with doing so could make such a decision unwise.

Backup Option and Future Prospects

A potential solution for the Browns would be to utilize Watson as a backup quarterback until the end of his contract. This would allow the team to manage the risk of Watson's continued subpar performance while also maintaining an experienced presence on the roster. Simultaneously, the Browns can focus on developing and grooming other quarterbacks to potentially take over the starting position in the future.

The alternative of developing a new starting QB could prove to be a more sustainable long-term strategy. Investing in new talent and nurturing young, developing quarterbacks could provide the Browns with a viable and fresher starting option once Watson's contract ends.

Conclusion

Given the complexities and challenges involved, the Browns should consider using Deshaun Watson as a backup until the end of his contract. This strategy allows for financial prudence and the continued presence of a seasoned quarterback while the team works on developing a capable starting QB. This approach balances immediate responsibilities with long-term planning and sustainability.

Ultimately, the Browns' decision will depend on a range of factors, including the outcome of legal proceedings, Watson's physical and mental health, and the progress of internal development of other quarterbacks. It is crucial for the Browns to maintain a strategic and thoughtful approach to ensuring the health and success of their team in the future.