Which MLB Player Had the Best Combined Career as Both a Player and a Broadcaster?

When considering which Major League Baseball (MLB) player excelled both in playing and broadcasting, several legends come to mind. Joe Morgan is one of the names often mentioned, but this article focuses on two specific players: Tim McCarver and Jay “Dizzy” Dean. Both demonstrated exceptional abilities in both roles, showcasing a unique blend of talent and passion. Let’s dive into their careers and achievements.

Tim McCarver: Catcher and Broadcasting Icon

Tim McCarver, a former Hall of Fame catcher and broadcaster, was one of the most recognizable figures in the baseball world. His impressive playing career, coupled with decades of successful broadcasting, makes him a standout candidate for the best combined player and broadcaster.

Playing Career

McCarver’s career as a catcher was marked by significant accolades and achievements. He began his professional career in 1959 and eventually became the everyday catcher for the St. Louis Cardinals in 1963. His tenure with the Cardinals saw him guiding their pitching staff to three World Series appearances, including victories in 1964 and 1967 over the Yankees and Red Sox, respectively. He was a key player, hitting the tie-breaking home run in Game 5 of the 1964 World Series and setting the NL record for triples by a catcher in 1967 (13 triples). Despite his numerous achievements, McCarver’s induction into the Hall of Fame was primarily due to his broadcasting career.

Broadcasting Career

After a few games each year from 1959 to 1975, McCarver found success in broadcasting. He was paired with Hall of Fame outfielder Richie Ashburn and future Ford C. Frick Award winner Harry Kalas in 1969 on WPHIL, the Phillies’ flagship station. His smooth transitions into broadcast roles paved the way for his national profile. McCarver joined NBC in 1980 as part of their national broadcast team, marking the beginning of his extensive career in broadcasting.

McCarver’s broadcasting career reached its peak with his involvement in 23 World Series from 1985 to 2013. He not only provided insightful commentary but also won three Emmy Awards for Sports Event Analyst, solidifying his status as a respected figure in baseball media. His insights and longevity in broadcasting, combined with his playing career, make him a prime candidate for the best combined player and broadcaster.

Jay "Dizzy" Dean: The Larger-than-Life Legend

Jay "Dizzy" Dean, another significant figure in baseball history, left an indelible mark both as a player and broadcaster. His dynamic career and legendary status make him an intriguing comparison to McCarver.

Playing Career

Dean’s career was filled with legendary feats and tales. From 1932 to 1937, he started 170 games, threw 123 complete games, won 120, lost 65, made 75 relief appearances, and notched 30 saves while totaling 1531 innings pitched. His ERA and WHIP stats were impressive, with a 3.04 ERA and 1.210 WHIP. At the All-Star break in 1937, Dean had a 12-7 record with one save in 20 games, 18 starts, and two relief appearances, but a line drive off Earl Averill broke his toe, leading to a shortened season. His arm was too hurt to pitch well after that, eventually leading to a transition into broadcasting.

After his playing days, Dean made a name for himself through his broadcasting career. He gained a following among Cardinals and Browns fans, moving to the Yankees and then the Mutual radio network, eventually joining ABC and CBS for their game of the week. Despite his raw, unpolished style, Dean was known for his deep knowledge of the game and his no-holds-barred approach during broadcasts.

Broadcasting Career

While Dean didn’t receive the Ford C. Frick Award during his playing career, his broadcasting career was highly respected. His unique and passionate personality, combined with his understanding and love for baseball, made him a beloved figure in the baseball community. Despite his raw style and the absence of a dedicated broadcasting award during his playing years, Dean’s contributions to baseball communication have left a lasting impact.

Legacy and Impact

Both Tim McCarver and Jay “Dizzy” Dean demonstrate an incredible skillset in both playing and broadcasting, making them strong candidates for the best combined player and broadcaster. While McCarver was more recognized for his broadcasting achievements, Dean’s larger-than-life personality and deep knowledge of the game made him a significant figure during his broadcasting career. Their legacies continue to resonate with fans and broadcasters alike.

The Ford C. Frick Award, however, overlooks some deserving figures like McCarver and Dean. As baseball history evolves, it’s crucial to recognize the contributions of all legends, regardless of their specific achievements. Both McCarver and Dean have left indelible marks on the game, making them worthy candidates for further recognition.