The Unfortunate Career of Forgotten Cricketers: A Case Study of Manoj Tiwary and Others

In the often-capped world of cricket, some stories stand out more than others. One such narrative revolves around cricketers who, despite showing promise and talent, tragically failed to secure a consistent position in the national team. This article delves into the story of Manoj Tiwary and draws parallels with other cricketers who faced similar challenges, exploring the role of selection, luck, and injury in shaping their careers.

Manoj Tiwary's Journey

Manoj Tiwary, a flamboyant middle-order batsman and a handy part-time leg-spinner, had a career marred by selection issues and injury woes. His rise to prominence came in the 2006–07 Ranji Trophy, where he scored nearly 800 runs, averaging close to 100. This impressive performance caught the eye of the national selectors and led to his inclusion in the Indian team slated to tour Bangladesh in 2007.

Unfortunately, Tiwary's journey was marked by setbacks. An injury sustained during fielding practice before his debut match in Mirpur put a premature end to his anticipation. When he finally made his debut in 2008, his performance against Brett Lee was overshadowed by lethargy from jet-lag, resulting in another disappointment.

A hiatus of three years followed, and when he returned to the national team in 2011, he managed to score his first and only ODI century against West Indies. However, this achievement did not secure his place in the team, and he was dropped after the match. Tiwary's final game in Indian colours came in 2015, and he retired shortly after, leaving behind a legacy intertwined with missed opportunities and untapped potential.

Lessons from Forgotten Heroes

Manoj Tiwary's story is not unique. Many cricketers in India have faced similar challenges. Ambati Rayudu, for example, should have been a regular in ODIs from 2014 instead of Stuart Binny, whose inclusion has been controversial. Similarly, Suresh Raina and Yusuf Pathan were dropped from T20Is despite their contributions to the team.

The Indian cricket team's approach to player selection has often been criticized. While specialists like Murali Vijay and Cheteshwar Pujara are given considerable support, Raina and Pathan, who are known for their versatility, do not receive the same treatment. The case of Irfan Pathan is another stark example—playing his last game at 28, not for a lack of skill, but due to lack of opportunities.

Other overlooked talents include Sanjay Bangar, who should have played in the 2003 World Cup, replacing Dinesh Mongia, and Sandeep Sharma, who deserved more chances in T20Is and at least one or two ODIs over Mohit Sharma. Robin Uthappa, who should have received more opportunities in T20Is, was overshadowed by Ajinkya Rahane.

Reflections and Conclusion

The careers of Tiwary and these underappreciated cricketers serve as a poignant reminder of the complex dynamics of player selection and performance. While talent and performance are crucial, luck and factors beyond a player's control can significantly impact their journey. The unfortunate truth is that many players like Tiwary are often denied a second chance, leaving behind a legacy of what could have been.

As the cricket community continues to reflect on these stories, it becomes evident that creating a more inclusive and equitable system for player selection is essential. The lessons from these forgotten cricketers should inspire a renewed focus on nurturing talent and providing stable opportunities to those who deserve a fighting chance.

Follow the journey of Manoj Tiwary and other forgotten cricketers to understand the challenges faced in the cricket world.

Image Credits: Google Images