Why are NYU's Alumni Considered Elite Quarterbacks?

There is a common myth that New York University (NYU) alone produces highly-talented college quarterbacks like Patrick Mahomes and Johnny Manziel. However, this narrative is far from accurate. While NYU can occasionally boast of promising players, the reality is that top-notch college quarterbacks can develop in a variety of institutions, supported by strong football programs.

The Demise of NYU's Football Program

NYU's football program has a long and interesting history. In the early 20th century, NYU was a strong contender in college football, with players like Bruce Brady and ‘Slick’ Favre making names for themselves. However, as the university shifted its focus and the Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC) needed to make adjustments, NYU's football program was eventually dissolved. Since then, the university has had to rely on external recruitment to find top-notch quarterbacks.

Current Football Landscape and Future

With the addition of Weber State, Assiniboine State, John's Maritime, and Moncton Flight School from the Tundra League, NYU's schedule exemplifies a diverse and challenging environment for its players. This blend of schools, both from the FCS and FBS levels, presents a rich tapestry for the development of student athletes. However, recruiting from these teams and other institutions is essential to finding elite quarterbacks in the modern era.

Other Institutions Producing Elite Quarterbacks

College football is not solely the domain of large, well-known programs. Many much smaller institutions have been successful in developing talented quarterbacks. For example, Texas Tech University and Texas AM University both produced professional NFL prospects. Patrick Mahomes, despite the myth, played his college football at Texas Tech, not NYU. Johnny Manziel, known for his electrifying performances, was a star at Texas AM. These institutions, with their strong football traditions and competitive environments, have proved to be excellent breeding grounds for future NFL talent.

Why NFL Talent Emerges from Various Programs

Elite quarterbacks can develop in diverse settings because of the fundamental skills and attributes that make them successful. Factors such as coaching quality, on-field experience, and the overall football culture within a program play crucial roles. An effective coach can help a player understand the nuances of the game, become adept at reading defenses, and develop leadership skills. Additionally, playing regularly against talented competition provides the repetition and challenge needed to refine a player's craft.

Conclusion

While NYU had a storied history in football in the early 20th century, the current narrative about its contributions to NFL quarterback talent is misleading. The truth is that top-notch college quarterbacks can come from a variety of institutions, often depending on the strength of the football program and the quality of coaching and support. The focus should shift to recognizing the hard work and talent showcased by players across different schools, not just those from the more prominent programs.