Who Would Win in a Fight Between Ezzard Charles and Anthony Joshua?

The outcome of a hypothetical fight between Ezzard Charles and Anthony Joshua would depend on various factors, including the rules of the bout, the weight class, and the fighters' conditions at the time of the fight. This essay explores the potential advantages and disadvantages of both fighters, providing insight into their strategies and boxing styles.

Overview of Ezzard Charles

Ezzard Charles was a heavyweight champion in the 1940s and 1950s, known for his exceptional boxing skills, speed, and ring IQ. Despite weighing around 180-190 pounds during his prime, Charles was highly skilled and had a great chin, which allowed him to withstand powerful punches.

Overview of Anthony Joshua

Anthony Joshua is a modern heavyweight with a size strength and athleticism that is evident in his typical weight of 240-250 pounds. His powerful punch and knockout ratio are significant advantages in the ring. However, Joshua has faced criticism for his defensive abilities and stamina in high-pressure situations. His style combines power with technical skills, reflecting a balanced approach to the sport.

Direct Matchup: Size and Power vs. Skill and Experience

Size and Power: Given Joshua's 6'6" and 240-250 pounds, he holds a significant physical advantage, which would likely translate into a crowd-pleasing display of power. Powerful punches and the ability to absorb punishment would be Joshua's primary weapons in such a bout.

Skill and Experience: Charles' technical skills and experience in the ring could give him a significant edge. His ability to outmaneuver Joshua, especially if he can avoid getting caught by Joshua's powerful punches, would be a critical determinant in the fight. Charles' speed and technique, honed over decades, could make him a formidable opponent who could dictate the pace of the fight.

The Modern Professional Boxing Rules

Under modern professional boxing rules, which emphasize striking power and knockout potential, Joshua may have an edge due to his size and power. His ability to move effectively and use his power could overwhelm Charles, forcing him into defensive modes where he may struggle to find his footing.

However, if the fight were held under more traditional boxing rules, Charles' speed and technique might prove more effective. His ability to stay elusive and apply pressure in the corners, combined with his powerful left hook, could prove detrimental to Joshua's stamina and defensive capabilities.

The BOXing Adage and Ezzard Charles

A commonly cited adage in boxing is that a great big man will always defeat a great little man. Ezzard Charles, a man of 6'0" and around 200 pounds, holds a legendary status in boxing history. He is generally considered one of the greatest light heavyweights of all time and is often mentioned in the same conversation as the likes of Sugar Ray Robinson and Muhammad Ali.

The weight difference between Charles and Joshua is significant, as Joshua is clearly taller and heavier. The real question is whether Anthony Joshua is one of the greatest fighters ever, capable of defeating such a notable opponent. Based on the analysis of both fighters' styles and past performances, the consensus among boxing experts is that every single one of the aforementioned great fighters (Larry Holmes, Ken Norton, Evander Holyfield, Lennox Lewis, and Mike Tyson) could beat Joshua in a boxing match.

However, they would all struggle against Ezzard Charles in his heyday. Charles' boxing IQ, technical skills, and powerful left hook would pose significant challenges, making it a fierce and intense battle. Even if they were to lose, it would be a captivating display of skill and determination.

Therefore, Anthony Joshua is not at the level where he could beat one of the greatest heavyweights ever, such as Ezzard Charles. His abilities and past performances, while impressive, fall short of the legendary status and skill set of boxing's greats.