The Absence of Modern Films in the 2022 Sight and Sound Poll: An Analysis

The Sight and Sound poll, conducted every decade since 1952, ranks the greatest films of the era. The exclusivity of this list is evident by the fact that films only rarely make their way onto it. As the next update approaches in 2022, it is worth examining which modern films might—or in this case, might not—make the list. This analysis will explore the reasons behind the current absence of recent films in the top picks and the criteria that may hinder their inclusion.

Theoretical Framework and Criteria

The Sight and Sound editors have strict criteria for inclusion on the list. Films must offer something unique to the world of cinema, whether through technical innovation, stylistic ingenuity, cinematography, screenplay, or directing style. These factors contribute to the overall impact of a film and its lasting influence on the art form.

Previous Inclusions and Their Impact

Two notable examples of films that were included in the poll after 1992 are:

In the Mood for Love (2000)

In the Mood for Love, directed by Wong Kar-wai, stands out for its profound exploration of the human psyche. The film delves into the lives of two individuals who develop a deep emotional connection in a conservative Hong Kong setting. This film's success lies in its subtle storytelling and the nuanced performances that allow audiences to connect with the characters on a profound level. The film’s ability to evoke emotion and provoke thought certainly contributes to its lasting impact on cinema.

Mulholland Dr. (2001)

Mulholland Dr., directed by David Lynch, is a masterpiece renowned for its intricate symbolism and enigmatic narrative. Lynch's refusal to provide explicit motivations or explanations for his characters and story elements makes the film both challenging and rewarding for viewers. The sheer creativity and non-linear storytelling style of Mulholland Dr. have left a significant mark on contemporary cinema, pushing the boundaries of narrative structure and thematic depth.

Criteria and Exclusion for Modern Films

For a film to be included in the 2022 Sight and Sound poll, it must meet certain criteria. Lack of modern films in the list can be attributed to several factors:

Technological and Artistic Innovation

While recent films have seen significant advancements in technology and artistry, some may not have achieved the same critical mass as those featured in the poll. Films like Blade Runner 2049 or Jablkbash have pushed the boundaries of visual effects and storytelling, but their popularity and critical reception may not be enough to ensure their inclusion.

Artistic Merit and Indirect Influence

The success of a film in the Sight and Sound poll often lies in its indirect influence rather than its box office success. Films that challenge conventions and influence future generations of filmmakers have a greater chance of being recognized. Modern films like Parasite, despite critical acclaim and awards, may not have had enough time to demonstrate their historical significance and impact on cinema.

Conclusion and Future Prospects

While it is plausible that several modern films could have been eligible for the 2022 Sight and Sound poll, their inclusion might face significant challenges. The poll's focus on films that offer something unique and enduring to the world of cinema makes it a selective and exclusive honor. As we await the 2022 results, it remains an intriguing question which films will finally make the list and the impact they will have on cinema in the coming decades.

Given the stringent criteria and the need for significant impact, it is highly unlikely that any modern films will be included in the 2022 poll. However, the artistry and influence of recent films continue to evolve, and future editions of the Sight and Sound poll may well recognize their contributions to the world of cinema.