NBA Doctors and Player Health Decisions: Who Has the Final Say?

The relationship between NBA players and team doctors often revolves around the debate of whether a player should return to the game after an injury. While it might seem logical that the player, eager to remain active, would have the final say, the reality is often more complex. Team doctors, who are part of the organization and have financial implications, often encourage players to return to the court as soon as possible. This dynamic leads many players to seek a second opinion from independent doctors to ensure their safety and long-term health.

The Team Doctor's Role and Influence

Team doctors, who are typically employed by the organization, have a vested interest in getting players back on the court. Their primary goal is to help the team win games. Therefore, it is not uncommon for these doctors to 'encourage' players to return to play, even if their injuries are not fully healed. For instance, in the playoffs, players like Joel Embiid have pushed through significant knee injuries, defying the advice of their team doctors.

One notable example is Michael Jordan, the legendary player who broke his leg during his early Chicago Bulls career. Despite the doctor’s recommendation against returning to play, Jordan insisted on continuing his games. As a franchise player and a top-tier talent in his era, his doctors and team may have hesitated to risk his long-term health by not getting him back on the court sooner.

The Perils of Overplaying through Injuries

Several players, including Kawhi Leonard, have suffered significantly due to playing through injuries. Initially, Leonard was given the green light by his San Antonio Spurs doctor to play through his injury, assuming it was a minor sprain. However, Leonard's condition worsened because he continued to play, ultimately developing a tear. Similar stories have emerged from other players, emphasizing the importance of proper medical advice.

Andrew Bynum, for instance, played through a knee injury during the season and waited until the next training camp to get the necessary surgery. This approach, while a common strategy for players, often results in delayed healing and potential long-term damage. Other players who played through various ankle sprains faced multiple surgeries and further complications.

The High Stakes and Pressure in the NBA

The pressure to win championships often overrides medical advice, especially for star players. Consider the case of Kevin Durant. Encouraged by his team, the Golden State Warriors, to return from a minor injury to save the team from defeat during a playoff series, Durant suffered a ruptured Achilles tendon. While the team doctors might have advised caution, they likely praised Durant and emphasized the importance of winning, as Durant had been a crucial player.

In contrast, many players have learned the hard way by ignoring their doctors’ advice. Shaquille O'Neal's toe injury in a previous season and the eventual surgery before the next season illustrate how even minor injuries can become major problems if ignored. Grant Hill, Johnson, and many others who played with injured ankles ended up requiring multiple surgeries, proving the risks associated with overplaying through injuries.

Conclusion

The relationship between NBA players and team doctors is a delicate balance between player health and team success. While players have the drive to compete and contribute to their teams, doctors often prioritize the immediate needs of the team. Seeking second opinions from independent doctors and understanding the potential long-term implications is critical for every player to ensure they make the best possible decisions for their health and careers.