Bret Hart: A Divide Between WWE and WCW

Bret Hart, once a prominent figure in both WWE and WCW, was considered a significant draw due to his technical prowess, in-ring storytelling, and merchandise success. However, his drawing power varied significantly between the two promotions. This article explores the extent of his drawing power in each and delves into the reasons behind any discrepancies.

WWE (WWF) Era

Early Career: Hart initially gained popularity as part of the Hart Foundation, a tag team that resonated strongly with fans. His technical wrestling ability and in-ring storytelling helped him build a strong fanbase. When he entered the main event spotlight in the late 1990s, his championship reigns, particularly during his championship reign, further solidified his as a key draw for the promotion. Notable events, such as WrestleMania 12, where he faced Shawn Michaels in the Iron Man match, showcased his enduring appeal and charismatic persona.

Main Event Status: Hart became a major draw in WWE, especially during his championship reigns. His technical skills and storytelling ability made him a crowd favorite, drawing in large audiences and contributing to the success of shows. Merchandise sales also reflected his popularity, indicating that fans were not only drawn to watch him on television but also wanted to emulate his style through merchandising.

WCW Era

Initial Reception: Upon joining WCW in 1997, Hart was a significant signing, especially following his high-profile departure from WWE. However, his drawing power was less impactful in WCW compared to his time in WWE. Several factors contributed to this, including the inconsistent booking and the heavy focus on the nWo storyline, which overshadowed other talent, including Hart.

Booking Issues: Hart's character and matches often suffered from poor booking decisions and a lack of compelling storylines. The promotion was heavily focused on the nWo storyline, which dominated the airwaves and overshadowed other talents. This overshadowing made it difficult for Hart to assert himself as a main event star, despite his numerous memorable matches and feuds.

Declining Ratings: While Hart had some notable matches and feuds in WCW, the overall ratings for events featuring him did not match those of top stars like Hulk Hogan, who remained a consistent draw throughout the promotion's run. The WCW's declining ratings during Hart's tenure highlight the broader issues facing the promotion, but it also underscores his limited drawing power in this setting.

Reasons for Limited Drawing Power

Timing: By the time Hart moved to WCW, the wrestling landscape had shifted. The focus was heavily on the nWo and other larger-than-life characters, which made it increasingly challenging for Hart to gain the same level of recognition as in WWE. The competition from the nWo faction and other established stars intensified his struggle to become the top draw.

Booking Decisions: Poor creative decisions and a lack of compelling storylines further diminished Hart's ability to draw as a main event star. The nWo storyline, while popular, left little room for Hart to shine on his own, overshadowing his own character and matches. These booking decisions ultimately had a negative impact on his drawing power in WCW.

Competition: The Monday Night Wars saw a rise in other stars and factions, making it increasingly difficult for Hart to stand out as a top draw. The environment was fierce, with established and rising stars each vying for the audience's attention. The competition from Hulk Hogan, Eric Bischoff, and other prominent figures made it particularly challenging for Hart to maintain his status as a main event draw.

Although Bret Hart was undoubtedly a talented wrestler and a significant draw in his prime, particularly in WWE, various factors contributed to his limited drawing power in WCW. These factors, including the wrestling landscape, booking decisions, and competition, helped shape his career trajectory and ultimately impacted the extent to which he could draw fans to his matches.