Almost to Cooperstown: Major League Baseball’s Players Who Will Never Get into the Hall of Fame

Baseball, a sport rich with tradition and history, has a Hall of Fame that honors the greatest players of all time. However, sometimes the greatest players, those who almost make it to Cooperstown, remain just that – almost there. Here, we delve into some notable Major League Baseball (MLB) players who, despite their immense contributions to the game, may never find their way into the Hall of Fame. Additionally, we highlight two Negro League players who deserve recognition in the Hall of Fame for their incredible achievements.

Almost Hall-of-Famer Starting Lineup

The following roster features players who, while highly skilled, have fallen just short of achieving the pinnacle of baseball: the Hall of Fame. Included in this lineup are:

Pitcher – Luis Tiant: Known for his electrifying performances and unique underhand style, Tiant's career statistics were overshadowed by personal issues and voter biases. Catcher – Thurman Munson: A legendary catcher for the New York Yankees, Munson's untimely passing during a plane crash at the age of 32 meant his legacy could never be fully celebrated. First Base – Don Mattingly: A long-time New York Yankee, Mattingly's offensive prowess was equally matched by his defensive skills, yet he lacks the recognition he deserves. Second Base – Lou Whitaker: A two-time Gold Glove award winner, Whitaker's consistent excellence and leadership on the field did not translate into the Hall of Fame ballot. Third Base – Ken Boyer: Known for his fielding and batting consistency, Boyer was often overlooked due to his loyalty to a single team. Short Stop – Nomar Garciaparra: Despite his incredible offensive output, Garciaparra's on-field conduct and public image sometimes detracted from his Hall of Fame candidacy.

Why Hall of Fame Voting Has Always Been Challenging

The Baseball Hall of Fame voting process has been criticized for being less about objective achievement and more about subjective factors such as player likability and personal feelings. Regardless of their true merit, voters sometimes favor certain players over others. For example, Albert Belle, who had impressive career stats, faced significant opposition due to his public persona, leading to limited Hall of Fame votes despite his elite performance.

Moreover, new statistical tools that highlight the value of older players have sometimes made them stronger candidates for induction. However, since these players often become ineligible before their statistics can fully reflect their true worth, their chances at the Hall of Fame diminish over time.

Disregarded Players Honored with Best Efforts

Even so, there are still 35 eligible non-Hall of Famers who, in my opinion, should be recognized for their contributions. Yet, I understand that writing a comprehensive analysis for each of them is not feasible. Instead, today, as the Negro Leagues Family Alliance pushes to have May 2 recognized as Negro Leagues Day, is a fitting opportunity to discuss two notable Negro League players who, in my view, deserve a place in the Hall of Fame.

John Donaldson – The Greatest Southpaw of the Negro Leagues

John Donaldson is widely regarded as one of the greatest southpaw pitchers in the Negro Leagues. He spent much of his career with barnstorming teams, resulting in sparse statistical data. However, based on research, it is believed that Donaldson won at least 400 games and struck out over 5,000 batters. In his 718 games pitched, he threw at least 14 no-hitters and two perfect games. His abilities as a pitcher and hitter, coupled with his strong defense in center field, make him a standout player in the era of Negro Leagues.

Dick Redding – The Cannonball of the Negro Leagues

Dick Redding is credited with having the most impressive fastball in the Negro Leagues, earning him the nickname “Cannonball.” Due to his semi-professional status, his full statistics are difficult to verify. But historical reports indicate that in 1912, Redding won an extraordinary 43 games and threw seven no-hitters, tying the all-time MLB career record. Additionally, he reportedly threw a remarkable 30 no-hitters throughout his career. Comparisons to legendary white league pitchers like Christy Mathewson and Walter Johnson underscore his talent and impact on the game.

A Call for Recognition

These players, like Donaldson and Redding, have proven themselves against formidable competition and deserve the recognition they have been denied. May the recognition and appreciation of their talents continue to grow, giving them their rightful place in the Hall of Fame in the future.