154 Games: The Right Move for MLB in 2021

In the midst of budget constraints and changes in sports scheduling due to the ongoing pandemic, the question of how many games Major League Baseball (MLB) should play in the 2021 season has become a topic of significant debate. My proposal is to have 154 games per season, played over a balanced schedule with each team facing 14 opponents within its league, played 11 times. Moreover, pennant winners would directly enter the World Series, eliminating the playoff rounds. This article delves into the arguments for and against this proposal, weighing the pros and cons from various perspectives.

Arguments for and Against

Advantages: A shorter, 154-game season offers several benefits. Firstly, it maximizes fan engagement and team efficiency without overwhelming players. The removal of interleague games reduces competition dilution and keeps the focus on divisional rivalries, thereby enhancing the championship atmosphere. Additionally, a balanced schedule ensures consistent play throughout the season, reducing the effects of cold weather starts and tired arm finishes.

A shorter season also aligns with a more traditional format, mirroring the 154-game schedule that prevailed for over six decades before the transition to 162 games. This change would bring a sense of familiarity and stability, which could be crucial for maintaining the league’s popularity and fan loyalty. Furthermore, it could slightly decrease conflicts with other sports schedules, providing players with more manageable off-season breaks.

Revenue and Player Concerns

Despite the benefits, there are several challenges to implementing this proposal. From a revenue perspective, MLB has committed to TV money and the corresponding programming needs to maintain sponsor interest rates. MLB's plan to expand playoffs and extend the season into November is designed to maximize revenues by increasing attendance and viewership.

The elimination of eight games, as proposed, could have a significant financial impact on players. For example, an 8-game reduction would cost a $10 million salary player approximately $500,000. This financial burden on players highlights the complex negotiation between the MLB Owners and the Players Association (MLBPA).

The MLBPA, led by Ken Rosenthal’s reports, has exclusively focused on maximizing player revenue. The union is likely to reject expanded playoffs due to the perceived inadequacy of the player guarantee pool, a key concern that must be addressed in CBA negotiations.

Pandemic and Negotiations

MLB owners proposed a one-month delay in the start of the season in combination with a 154-game schedule. The rationale behind this move is to mitigate the financial impact of the pandemic while still providing a robust competitive environment for the teams. However, the allure of maintaining larger revenues through expanded playoffs and late-season games may deter owners from fully aligning with a shorter season.

While the owners’ proposal may have some appeal, the players’ current stance and the union’s focus on financial security for its members challenge the feasibility of a shorter season. However, I remain optimistic that MLB can find a middle ground that respects both financial prudence and the competitive integrity of the sport.

Conclusion

Given the historical significance and the need for a balanced schedule, I would prefer a 150-game season. However, 154 games offer a good compromise that maintains the spirit of tradition while addressing modern scheduling challenges. As negotiations continue, it's essential for all stakeholders to consider the long-term benefits of a more balanced and less taxing season for players and fans alike.